Mediterranean Diet vs Paleo Diet Showdown: What's Best for You?

The Mediterranean Diet vs Paleo Diet? Which one should you pick? In this article, we cover the key foods, studies, effectiveness for weight loss, environmental sustainability, critiques, and risks of both diets so that you can ultimately make the best decision for your health and lifestyle.

This article contains affiliate links which supports us at no extra cost to you.

Jump To

History of the Mediterranean Diet
Key foods in the Mediterranean Diet
Scientific studies supporting the Mediterranean Diet
Effectiveness of the Mediterranean Diet for weight loss
Environmental sustainability of the Mediterranean Diet
Critiques and risks associated with the Mediterranean Diet
History of the Paleo Diet
Key foods in the Paleo Diet
Scientific studies supporting the Paleo Diet
Effectiveness of the Paleo Diet for weight loss
Environmental sustainability of the Paleo Diet
Critiques and risks associated with the Paleo Diet
Mediterranean Diet vs Paleo Diet: Which One Should You Pick?
Mediterranean and Paleo Recipes

History of the Mediterranean Diet

The Mediterranean Diet is more than food. It's a lifestyle from the Greek "díaita." It's about farming, fishing, cooking, eating. Essentially, it's tied to seasons, religion, Mediterranean communities.

It got noticed in the 1950s for health benefits. Ancel and Margaret Keys made it famous in 1975. They tied it to Mediterranean climate and culture.

UNESCO calls it Intangible Cultural Heritage. It's not just nutrition; it's about community, neighborliness, passing down knowledge.

What's in it? Lots of olive oil, fruits, veggies, fiber. Some fish, poultry. Low in saturated fat, high in good fats and polyphenols. It's linked to less heart disease, diabetes, certain cancers, obesity. Better for your brain and mood, too.

It varies by country, reflecting different ethnic, cultural, economic, religious backgrounds. Shows its adaptability and wide appeal.

Key foods in the Mediterranean Diet

Mediterranean Diet basics:

Eat 2-3 fruits and 4+ veggies daily.
Go for whole grains: bread, cereal, pasta, bulgur, barley, farro.
Use plant oils like olive or canola, not butter.
Fish or shellfish 2-3 times a week, low in mercury.
Nuts: aim for four raw, unsalted servings a week.
Dairy? Stick to low-fat milk, cottage cheese, Greek or plain yogurt.
Less red and processed meat. Try fish, poultry, beans.
Use herbs and spices, not salt.
This diet's big on plants, healthy fats, and moderate animal products.

Scientific studies supporting the Mediterranean Diet

Recent studies show the Mediterranean diet's packed with health benefits. Here's the scoop:

It cuts chronic disease risk. Research links it to lower cardiovascular disease. It fits well with dietary guidelines, but watch sodium and saturated fat.

Good for 'cardiodiabesity' - that's cardiovascular, diabetic, and obesity issues. It's about low fat oils and high vegetable oils.

Healthy aging? Women on this diet are 46% more likely to age healthily. That's living over 70 without major health or mental declines.

Alcohol's tricky. Even a bit can up the risk of high blood pressure and heart issues. Best to check with a doctor or dietitian.

To follow it, eat more fruits, veggies, whole grains, seafood. Choose unsaturated fats over saturated. Cut back on red and processed meats. Nuts, low-fat dairy, and herbs and spices are also key.

References:

Eguaras S, Toledo E, Hernández-Hernández A, Cervantes S, Martínez-González MA. "The Mediterranean diet and health: a comprehensive overview." PubMed. 2015.
García-Fernández E, Rico-Cabanas L, Rosgaard N, Estruch R, Bach-Faig A. "Mediterranean diet and cardiodiabesity: a review." Nutrients. 2014.
Willett WC, Sacks F, Trichopoulou A, et al. "Mediterranean diet pyramid: a cultural model for healthy eating." AJCN. 1995.
Fung TT, Rexrode KM, Mantzoros CS, Manson JE, Willett WC, Hu FB. "Mediterranean diet and incidence of and mortality from coronary heart disease and stroke in women." Circulation. 2009.
Bowen KJ, Sullivan VK, Kris-Etherton PM, Petersen KS. "Nutrition and Cardiovascular Disease-an Update." Curr Atheroscler Rep. 2018.
Mayo Clinic. "Mediterranean diet for heart health."

Effectiveness of the Mediterranean Diet for weight loss

The Mediterranean Diet and weight loss?

Comparing diets? A review stacked it against low-fat, low-carb, and American Diabetes Association diets. It beat low-fat and matched others over a year or more.

Long-term? It's good for lasting weight loss. Does well against other diets in lowering blood pressure and cholesterol.

Weight loss range? Between -4.1 to -10.1 kg over 12 months on this diet.

Beyond weight loss, it's great for overall health, especially heart health.

So, the Mediterranean Diet works for weight loss, similar to other diets. But its heart health perks make it stand out for a healthy life

References:

"Systematic Review of the Mediterranean Diet for Long-Term Weight Loss." PubMed. PubMed.

Environmental sustainability of the Mediterranean Diet

Beyond being healthful, the Mediterranean diet is also environmentally beneficial. This is the summary:

Its influence on the environment is minimal. Less processed food, dairy, and ruminant meat than diets typical in the West. Plants provide a reduced water footprint and release less greenhouse gases.

Both society and the economy benefit from it. Sustains regional economies and dietary customs.

It's sustainable in terms of nutrition. There is a problem, however. In nations around the Mediterranean, younger people are not adhering to it as much.

In summary, for sustainable eating and healthful eating, the MedDiet is a good option.

References:

See Frontiers in Nutrition, Public Health Nutrition, and related research for further information.

Critiques and risks associated with the Mediterranean Diet

The Mediterranean Diet's great, but it's got some downsides.

Weight gain's a risk. It's easy to overeat high-calorie stuff like olive oil and nuts without strict rules.

Groceries can cost more. Fresh fruits, veggies, whole grains, fish - they're pricier than processed foods.

Check with your doctor first. The diet includes red wine, but that's bad news with certain meds or health issues like uncontrolled diabetes, pancreatitis, or GERD.

Digestive troubles? If you've got celiac disease or lactose intolerance, this diet might not sit well.

History of the Paleo Diet

The Paleo Diet's story goes like this:

Started in the 1970s by gastroenterologist Walter Voegtlin. He wrote "The Stone Age Diet," pitching eating like our Paleolithic ancestors.

In the 1980s, Dr. Stanley Eaton expanded Voegtlin's ideas. His paper "Paleolithic Nutrition" and book "The Paleolithic Prescription" made the diet known.

Then Dr. Loren Cordain stepped in. Totally inspired by Eaton, he researched ancestral diets further and came up with his 2002 book "The Paleo Diet" made the idea much more mainstream.

The diet's based on the idea that our genes really haven't changed that much since the Paleolithic era. But, it's all about eating stuff you could hunt or gather – meats, fish, fruits, veggies, nuts, seeds. And that means definitely no dairy, grains, or processed foods.

But there's criticism (more on that below). The diet assumes ancient diets were uniform, not considering different geographies and cultures of our ancestors.

Key foods in the Paleo Diet

The Paleo Diet's about eating like in the Paleolithic era. Here's what's on the menu:

Meats: Think grass-fed meats, poultry, turkey, pork tenderloin, chops, steak, veal, bacon, lamb. Seafood's in too – shrimp, lobster, plus wild stuff like bison, venison.

Fish and Seafood: Bass, salmon, halibut, mackerel, sardines, tuna, red snapper, even shark.

Vegetables: Load up on asparagus, avocados, artichoke hearts, Brussels sprouts, carrots, spinach, celery, broccoli, zucchini, cabbage.

Oils and Fats: Use coconut, olive, macadamia, avocado oils. Grass-fed butter and ghee are good too.

Nuts and Seeds: Almonds, cashews, hazelnuts, pecans, pine nuts, sesame, pumpkin, sunflower seeds, macadamias, walnuts, chia seeds.

Fruits: Apples, avocados, blackberries, papayas, peaches, plums, mangoes, lychees, blueberries, grapes, dragon fruit, lemons, strawberries, watermelon, limes, raspberries, cantaloupes, tangerines, figs, oranges, bananas.

Scientific studies supporting the Paleo Diet

Here's what science says about the Paleo Diet:

It's about fresh lean meats, fish, eggs, nuts, seeds, fruits, veggies. No grains, dairy, legumes, refined sugars, oils, processed foods.

Short-term, it's shown some wins over other diets. More weight loss, smaller waists, better blood pressure, insulin sensitivity, cholesterol. But these studies are small, short.

A bigger trial with 70 Swedish women over two years compared it to the Nordic diet. Paleo beat it in fat loss at 6 months, not at 24. It did drop triglyceride levels.

But there are worries. It might miss nutrients like calcium, vitamin D. Planning meals and higher costs are challenges. Plus, eating a lot of meat has health risks.

Long-term effects and safety? That's still a question. We need bigger, longer studies for clear health benefits.

References:

Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health. (n.d.). Paleo Diet for Weight Loss. The Nutrition Source. Retrieved from Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health

Effectiveness of the Paleo Diet for weight loss

The Paleo Diet's all about whole foods – meat, fish, fruits, veggies. No dairy, grains, legumes, processed stuff. It's eating like our ancient ancestors.

For weight loss? Some research backs it. One study found a 11% body weight drop in six months on Paleo, versus 6% on a low-fat diet. No need to count calories.

Compared to other diets? Its trials are small. It's like low-carb or Atkins but skips grains and dairy, unlike the Mediterranean diet.

But there are downsides. Skipping dairy, grains, legumes might mean missing nutrients like calcium and B vitamins. Lots of meat could up risks of heart disease and diabetes. And it's tough to stick to long-term, which can lead to diet stress, lethargy.

What about chronic diseases? It might impact things like diabetes, heart disease, but the proof isn't solid. We need bigger, longer studies.

References:

Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health, "Paleo Diet for Weight Loss", Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health
Signos, "Paleo Diet for Weight Loss: How It Works + Pros & Cons", Signos
Second Nature, "The paleo diet: Is it good for you?", Second Nature

Environmental sustainability of the Paleo Diet

The Paleo Diet's big on meat, which ups the carbon footprint. Meat production needs lots of resources and contributes to greenhouse gases, deforestation, and water use.

Compared to vegan, vegetarian, or Mediterranean diets, Paleo's less green. Plant-based diets use fewer resources. The Mediterranean diet uses local, seasonal foods, which lowers its carbon footprint.

Making Paleo greener? Choose quality, responsible proteins. Support local farms with pastured, well-fed animals. This boosts biodiversity and beats the impact of large-scale animal farms.

Paleo's about whole, unprocessed foods. This cuts down on monoculture farming, bad for the environment. Supporting diverse food systems is key.

But modern Paleo often means lots of beef, maybe not true to ancient diets.

Better choices? Chicken, eggs, turkey – more efficient proteins.

Critiques and risks associated with the Paleo Diet

The Paleo Diet skips dairy, grains, legumes. This can mean missing out on calcium, vitamin D, B vitamins. That raises risks of osteoporosis, fractures, rickets.

It's heavy on protein, mainly from meat. Means more saturated fats, possibly upping cholesterol and heart disease risk. Too much protein can be hard on kidneys, especially if they're already weak.

A lot of red meat ups the risk of heart diseases, thanks to saturated fats.

Historically? It's off. Early humans likely ate more plants or were omnivores, not big meat-eaters. Paleo's meat focus doesn't fit that.

It also cuts carbs, even whole grains. Not great for athletes or high-energy lifestyles.

Sticking to Paleo long-term is tough. Might not keep weight off or help with long-term diseases like diabetes. Needs more study.

If you have heart, kidney issues, or osteoporosis risks, talk to a doc before starting Paleo. Its high protein and fat could be extra risky for you.

Mediterranean Diet vs Paleo Diet: Which One Should You Pick?

Choosing Mediterranean or Paleo? Depends on your health goals, tastes, and lifestyle. Here's a quick guide:

Mediterranean Diet:

It's diverse. Includes fruits, veggies, whole grains, olive oil, nuts, seeds. Fish, poultry, dairy in moderation; less red meat. Good for the heart, easy to stick with. Moderate wine's okay. Women, one glass a day; men, two. Good for aging, cognitive function. Linked to longer telomeres, less age-related disease. Great for heart health, may boost lifespan.

Paleo Diet:

All about whole, unprocessed foods. Think meats, fish, nuts, greens, regional veggies, seeds. No processed stuff, grains, sugar. Chosen for weight loss, metabolism boost. It's high-protein, low-carb. May cut inflammation and allergies, ditching processed foods, dairy, grains. Popular with athletes for energy, performance. High protein, low carb.

Specific needs or goals?

Heart health, disease prevention: Go Mediterranean. Balanced, varied, includes healthy fats, fiber. Weight loss, big diet shift: Paleo's better. Focuses on whole, unprocessed foods. Worried about aging, brain health: Mediterranean's linked to healthy aging, longer telomeres. Food allergies, sensitivities: Paleo might work, no dairy or grains.

Both diets have perks. Your choice should match your health goals, preferences, conditions. Always best to talk to a healthcare provider or nutritionist for tailored advice.